On this page (7)
Why this topic matters
Derivatives and hedging (Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 815) is one of the most technical areas in Business Analysis and Reporting (BAR). The exam tests whether an instrument is a derivative, how derivatives are measured, and how the three hedge accounting models change where gains and losses are reported.
What is a derivative?
A financial instrument or other contract is a derivative if it has all three characteristics:
- Underlying and notional amount (or payment provision): an underlying is a variable such as an interest rate, commodity price, exchange rate, or index; the notional is a number of units (for example, 10,000 bushels or $1 million).
- No initial net investment, or one smaller than would be required for similar exposure.
- Net settlement: the contract can be settled net in cash, through a market mechanism, or by delivering an asset readily convertible to cash.
Common derivatives: forwards (customized, over the counter, settled at maturity), futures (standardized, exchange-traded, settled daily), options (the right but not the obligation — calls to buy, puts to sell; the buyer pays a premium), and swaps (exchanges of cash flows, such as fixed for variable interest).
Scope exceptions
- Normal purchases and normal sales: contracts to buy or sell goods in quantities expected to be used or sold in the normal course of business, with probable physical delivery, may be excluded by election.
- Regular-way security trades, certain insurance contracts, and contracts indexed to the entity's own equity and classified in equity.
Embedded derivatives
A derivative feature within a host contract (for example, a commodity-indexed payment in a debt instrument) must be bifurcated and accounted for separately if: its economic characteristics and risks are not clearly and closely related to the host; the hybrid instrument is not already measured at fair value through earnings; and a separate instrument with the same terms would be a derivative. Alternatively, the entity may elect fair value for the whole hybrid.
Measurement
- All derivatives are recognized as assets or liabilities at fair value on the balance sheet.
- Without hedge accounting, changes in fair value go to net income immediately.
- Hedge accounting changes the timing of recognition so that gains and losses on the hedge and the hedged item are recognized in earnings together.
The three hedge accounting models
| Fair value hedge | Cash flow hedge | Net investment hedge | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hedges exposure to | Changes in the fair value of a recognized asset, liability, or firm commitment | Variability in future cash flows of a forecasted transaction or a variable-rate instrument | Foreign currency exposure of a net investment in a foreign operation |
| Example | Swapping fixed-rate debt to variable; hedging a firm commitment to buy equipment in euros | Swapping variable-rate debt to fixed; hedging a forecasted inventory purchase | A euro-denominated loan hedging a European subsidiary |
| Hedging instrument's gain or loss | Net income | Other comprehensive income (OCI), reclassified to earnings when the hedged transaction affects earnings | OCI (cumulative translation adjustment) until the foreign operation is sold |
| Hedged item | Carrying amount adjusted for the hedged risk; the change goes to net income | No adjustment (the transaction hasn't happened yet) | — |
EXAMPLE (fair value hedge): A company holds inventory it expects to sell in three months and enters a futures contract to lock in the selling price. The inventory's fair value falls $20,000 and the futures gain $19,000. Both are recognized in earnings: a $20,000 loss on the inventory (adjusting its carrying amount) and a $19,000 gain on the futures — net effect $1,000.
EXAMPLE (cash flow hedge): A company with variable-rate debt enters a pay-fixed, receive-variable swap. When rates fall, the swap's fair value becomes a $15,000 liability. The $15,000 loss goes to OCI and is reclassified into interest expense as the hedged interest payments occur, so interest expense reflects the fixed rate.
Qualifying for hedge accounting
- Formal documentation at inception: the hedging relationship, risk management objective and strategy, the hedging instrument, the hedged item, the nature of the risk, and how effectiveness will be assessed.
- The hedge must be expected to be highly effective — offsetting changes in fair value or cash flows within a range of roughly 80% to 125%.
- Forecasted transactions must be probable.
- After the Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2017-12 simplifications:
- Ineffectiveness is no longer measured separately. For cash flow hedges, the entire change in the hedging instrument's fair value (if highly effective) goes to OCI.
- The hedging instrument's earnings effect is presented in the same income statement line as the hedged item.
- Qualitative effectiveness assessments are allowed after an initial quantitative test.
- Private companies have additional relief (including a simplified hedge accounting approach for certain swaps).
Discontinuing a hedge
- A hedge is discontinued if criteria are no longer met, the derivative expires or is sold, or the designation is removed.
- For a cash flow hedge, amounts in accumulated OCI stay there until the forecasted transaction affects earnings — unless it is probable the transaction will not occur, in which case they are reclassified to earnings immediately.
Disclosures
Objectives and strategies for using derivatives, the location and fair value of derivatives on the balance sheet, gains and losses by hedge type and income statement line, and credit-risk-related contingent features.
How it is tested
- Decide whether a contract is a derivative or qualifies for a scope exception.
- Classify a hedge as fair value, cash flow, or net investment.
- State where the derivative's gain or loss is reported.
- Apply documentation and effectiveness requirements.
EXAM TIP: "Firm commitment" or "existing fixed-rate item" → fair value hedge → earnings. "Forecasted transaction" or "variable-rate item" → cash flow hedge → OCI first. Most hedge questions are solved by that distinction alone.